How to Turn Catering Guests Into Repeat Guests

This article outlines:
The operational basics that protect catering margin
Three ways to turn catering guests into regulars
Five ways to win repeat catering business from planners
As Eminem put it, “What if you had one shot, one opportunity?” With catering, every order comes with a fresh audience and a chance to earn repeat guests. But you only get one shot at making a great first impression. So how do you turn catering into a repeat-revenue machine?
Restaurants turn catering into repeat business in two directions. First, make the food memorable and traceable for the people who eat it, with branded packaging, a QR offer, and a high-quality delivery and handoff experience – that’s, of course, on time. Second, make the next order effortless for the guest who placed it, with fast follow-up, event-based reminders, and easy re-ordering and customization options.
To give you perspective on the massive potential behind catering, on Olo, business catering revenue on Olo grew 86% year over year in 2025, and a business catering order averages $392, nearly 16 times a standard mealtime order. How does that translate to individual mealtime guests? In ezCater's 2026 research, 62% of employees who first tried a restaurant at work later ordered from it on their own, and 67% recommended it to friends and family.
"Even though we've only recently launched Olo, we've already seen encouraging signs. Guests are placing larger online orders, and we've started seeing more catering activity through our direct ordering channels." — Eduardo Plascencia, Co-Founder & CEO, Tacos N' Tortas, in Olo’s Now Serving blog
What should restaurants fix before trying to grow catering?
Get the operational basics right first: efficient ordering, tiered packages, and accurate lead times. Repeat business happens only when each order is profitable and delivered on time. A late or wrong first order can end the relationship before any follow-up can even start.
- Make ordering efficient. Primary catering contacts are busy and often ordering for a group they don't know well. Clear headcount guidance, photos, allergen information, and a short path to checkout reduce back-and-forth and errors. Descriptive menus with photos, dietary options, drinks, and desserts make it easier for customers to say yes.
- Build tiered packages. Good, better, best bundles (for example, a boxed-lunch tier, a buffet tier, and a buffet-plus-dessert tier) make the choice easy and let you price for margin. They also make production more predictable.
- Set lead times your kitchen can keep. Start conservative and shorten them as your team builds confidence. Add longer lead times for slow-prep items and for peak seasons, and cap how many catering orders land in your busiest windows. Our post on the catering capacity crunch walks through lead times, throttling, and production sheets in detail.
What to do now: Audit your last 20 catering orders. Note which ones needed a phone call to clarify, which ran late, and which packages sold best. Fix those three things before you invest in growth. Our catering checklist is a great resource to guide your audit.
How do you turn catering clients into regulars?
Make it easy for guests to remember what they ate, where it came from, and why they should come back. Most people at a catered lunch never see the order confirmation. Your packaging and what's inside the bag are the only way you reach them.
1. Use branded packaging with clear labels. Branded containers and labeled menu items help guests remember what they liked and where it came from (and the 10 other people enjoying the same order). Foil trays with no name on them are a missed opportunity. At this year's Restaurant Catering Workshop, branded packaging was predicted to become mandatory for exactly this reason: a catering spread is often the first time a room full of people sees a brand up close. Label each dish by name, and flag dietary details like vegetarian or gluten-free so guests can find their favorite again.
2. Include a QR code with an offer. A simple card in the bag ("Enjoyed lunch? Here's an offer for your next visit") reaches dozens of people who may never have tried your brand. Use a unique code per order or per catering client. That makes catering-driven visits trackable, so you can see which offices send you new regulars.
3. On larger orders, add something for free. Include a new menu item, a dessert tray, or a side sample. It introduces guests to more of the menu than the planner would pick on their own, and it reads as hospitality, not a pitch.
What to do now: Pick one location and run a 30-day test. Add a card with a unique QR code to every catering order and count redemptions. This experiment gives you firm data and insight into potential conversion rates and repeat guest behavior.
How do restaurants win repeat catering business?
Focus on the planner, the office manager, or admin who placed the order. They decide where the next order comes from. Make that next order faster, more personal, and less risky than shopping around.
This is where most catering revenue lives. Across business catering on Olo, the top 10% of catering clients drive nearly half of business catering revenue, at more than twice the average order value of everyone else.
1. Follow up within a day or two. Send a short thank-you with one feedback question and a one-click link to reorder the exact same order. The easier the second order, the more likely it is to happen. While you're on-site, ask for referrals. People love to share, and nothing beats word-of-mouth marketing, so a small incentive for referring a colleague or another office can pay off.
2. Send reminders based on the event, not the calendar. If someone ordered for a December holiday party, a reminder next October beats a generic promo. The same goes for recurring meetings, Q1 kickoffs, graduation season, and back-to-school. Most of these dates are already in your order history; marketing automation can send the reminder so no one on your team has to track it.
3. Reward the client directly. Office managers and admins order on someone else's budget. Perks aimed at them personally, like a handwritten thank-you card or a free item on their next solo visit, build brand preference.
4. Remove friction for corporate clients. House accounts, invoicing, rebuilding a previous saved order in one click, and stored payment methods make your brand the default when the next order comes up. Tax-exempt handling matters too for schools, nonprofits, and religious groups, which often order on a regular schedule.
5. Offer a human contact. A named catering manager or a direct line matters for large or complex orders. It gives the guest someone to call instead of shopping around. Viva Chicken, which runs a dedicated catering call center, keeps that personal touch even at volume:
"Some of our guests expect concierge-level service; they order every week and know exactly what they want. Others have never ordered catering before and need guidance… we can pull up a guest's history the second they call." — Amanda Quinn, Director of Catering, Viva Chicken
What to do now: List your top 20 catering clients by revenue. For each, note the last order date, the occasion, and who placed it. Set a reminder for the next likely occasion and send a personal note to anyone who has gone quiet.
The bottom line
Every catering order is a chance to meet a room full of new guests and earn a business’ trust. Get the basics right, make your food memorable, and make the next order easier than the first. Small habits, applied consistently, turn one-time orders into a dependable catering business.
Want more practical ideas? Download the Catering Growth Playbook, take a spin through the interactive Catering Readiness Roadmap to see where your program stands, or watch the Catering 101 webinar with Bojangles and CRUMBS.
Frequently asked questions
How soon should a restaurant follow up after a catering order? Within one to two days, while the event is still fresh. Keep it short: a thank-you, one feedback question, and a link to reorder the same order.
What's the best way to track whether catering brings in new guests? Put a QR code with a unique offer code in every catering order. Redemptions show how many guests visited afterward and which catering clients send you the most new ones.
Who should restaurants market to for repeat catering orders? The planner, usually an office manager, admin, or event coordinator. They choose the restaurant, often order on someone else's budget, and respond well to personal recognition and easy reordering.
How far ahead should catering reminders go out? Tie them to the event, not a fixed schedule. For annual events like holiday parties, about two months ahead works well. For recurring meetings, send a reminder a few days before each one.
Do catering marketplaces help or hurt repeat business? Marketplaces are a strong way to get introduced to new catering clients. To build the relationship, use branded packaging and a clear path to your own catering site so repeat orders can come to you directly.