Captain D's | Olo Case Study

30% Higher Spend, 2x Online Orders: How Captain D's Rebuilt Its Digital Business

Captain D's has been serving seafood since 1969—but keeping up with how guests want to order today is a different challenge entirely. With more than 520 locations across the United States, the brand needed online ordering and loyalty tools that were easy for guests to use and easy for the team to manage—without getting locked into technology that would limit growth. By partnering with Olo, Captain D's overhauled its digital systems: Ordering and Serve gave guests a smoother, more intuitive ordering experience, while Loyalty replaced a cumbersome, password-dependent program with a simple phone-number-first experience that made signing up and earning rewards feel effortless. The result: online ordering more than doubled, loyalty membership grew 42%, and loyalty members now spend 30% more than non-members.


42%

Increase in loyalty membership year-over-year

30%

Higher spend from loyalty members vs. non-members

58%

Growth in SMS subscribers since program launch

>2x

Growth in online orders

Captain D's | Olo Case Study

Background

Captain D's occupies a distinctive niche in the QSR world: the experience of a sit-down meal delivered at fast-food speed and price. With a loyal guest base and a growing footprint, the brand recognized that its approach to online ordering and loyalty had not kept pace with how guests wanted to engage.

The previous online ordering front end was clunky and required too much manual work for simple tasks such as promoting limited-time offers. While the provider always promised improvements, they never materialized. Meanwhile, the loyalty provider required guests to remember passwords, navigate cumbersome account flows, and jump through hoops just to redeem a reward—the opposite of what a fast-food brand should offer. The legacy systems provided little insight into who guests actually were or how they wanted to be reached, making it difficult to develop a solid loyalty strategy.

Captain D's overhauled its digital infrastructure, with a firm requirement: it did not want another monolithic, all-in-one platform that would lock it into a rigid technology stack or make it hard to adapt as the industry evolved. Kiosks, AI-powered drive-thrus, and touchless ordering were already emerging as the next frontier. Captain D's needed a partner that could grow with the brand.

Olo rose to the top of the evaluation for its forward-thinking roadmap and clear status as an industry leader with reliable, capable technology. First, the team migrated to Olo for online ordering and implemented Serve, a conversion-optimized, white-label ordering experience for web and mobile that’s included with Ordering.

For Loyalty, Olo offered the flexibility Captain D's needed. A simple, passwordless phone-number-first enrollment process removed the biggest barrier to guest sign-up. Integration with the brand's existing Olo online ordering platform was seamless. And crucially, Olo Loyalty could scale and pivot as Captain D's strategy evolved.


Results with Olo

01 

A loyalty program worth joining

The single most impactful change Olo Loyalty delivered was making it easy to join and stay engaged. The passwordless, phone-number-first system eliminated the login friction that had long been the program's biggest dropout point. Guests could enroll quickly—at the counter, online, or via a keyword text campaign—without creating yet another account they'd forget. Within a year, loyalty membership grew by 42% over the prior year, and roughly 15% of enrolled members actively used the program monthly—nearly double the industry norm of 7–9%.

02 

Knowing your guest pays off

Olo Loyalty's identity management capabilities gave Captain D's a clearer picture of its guests and how to communicate with them. Rather than relying on blanket coupons, the brand could personalize outreach across channels—email, SMS, and in-app—based on how individual guests prefer to engage, resulting in 30% more spend than non-members, even after factoring in reward discounts. Email subscribers grew 47%, and SMS opt-ins—a newer channel for the brand—grew 58%. Keyword campaigns like "text LOBSTER for a free reward" drove a week's worth of new SMS subscribers in a single day. As Captain D's expanded loyalty to in-store and dine-in guests, the redemption process was effortless for both guests and employees: Guests could choose their reward in the app beforehand, then scan a QR code at the counter to apply it.

03 

A flexible platform built for what's next

Captain D’s saw immediate benefits by migrating to Olo Serve—online orders increased in the first month. Onboarding new stores once took 7–10 days; now it's nearly instantaneous. Captain D’s had a complex menu with modifiers and side options, and Serve highlighted all the options with eye-catching photos, making ordering easy and error-free. Since migrating to Olo, the brand has increased its digital ordering mix from roughly 5% of total sales to approximately 10%, with select locations reaching up to 40%—growth the brand attributes in part to a guest experience that simply works.

Where other restaurants are stuck in all-in-one solutions they can’t unbundle, Captain D's chose Olo Loyalty precisely because it wouldn't box in the brand’s capabilities. The flexibility positions Captain D's to tackle its next frontier: reaching drive-thru guests (historically the hardest segment to engage) and converting anonymous transactions into trackable loyalty relationships.




After doing just one keyword campaign, we saw in one week what normally takes a month to build organically. Olo Loyalty made it easy for guests to join, easy for operators to execute, and easy for us to grow.

Keith Canseco, Senior Director of National Marketing, Captain D's

Captain D's


More customer success

What are you waiting for?

Transform your guest experience today.